Tools and Trouble Spots: A Final Reflection

My wife teaches English to refugees, and the other day we had a conversation about what it's like to teach a new language to students who are completely illiterate even in their old language. Some of them don't even know how to hold a pencil. I like to look at their artwork; it's like a child drew it. Makes you smile even more when you know it's drawn by a 40-year-old man.

One of the things she's noticed is that students who do not have experience with reading and writing lack the skills and strategies to tackle Gallagher's "trouble-spots," the places where confusion tends to arise. They have difficulty looking for context clues. They don't think to sound words out. Often when they get stuck, they stay stuck, because they lack the tools to solve their problems.

The trouble is that we very rarely recognize that we're missing out on strategies for doing our work. Rather, it's easier for a student to internalize failure and believe that it's about a lack of ability rather than a lack of knowledge. My wife tells me stories about students who fake knowing, who memorize what others are reading, who get put in the wrong classes because they can cheat the placement exams. She also tells me about students who despair, who say they just can't read, though she knows better. 

I think many of our students will get stuck in the same way––lots of them smart kids who simply lack the tools to become effective readers and thinkers. I think one of the things theory does so well is to bring strategies for reading, for overcoming trouble-spots and arriving at understanding meaning, out into the open. Imagine how daunting it would be to learn construction, for example, if your boss never showed you he was using tools! With the right tools, it's something almost anyone could learn. If students know about the tools we use to arrive at meaning, I think they will be much less likely to feel alienated from the text or to blame their lack of understanding on inability. Learning theory is so different from learning many of the things I learned in English class. There's really no way to fake it. The application of these critical tools is a skill; either you've learned it or you haven't. I think learning theory begins to put the value back into ELA classrooms, which have the potential to become little more than glorified book clubs with lessons in Eurocentrism. The time spent musing on theories and strategies for teaching English this semester has been enlightening and beneficial. I, for one, am thankful for it.

Stefan Luchian - At Nami (wood cutter)

Not Just Reading the World as It Used To Be

No one would argue against the idea that the internet has changed the way we communicate. Just today, the course of my procrastination took me to two articles about the role of social media in defining America. One article told the story of how the Obama campaign made use of its tumblr to rally its young supporters to go out and vote. The other posted examples of the way a "twitter bot" has become an advocate for both good grammar and the respect of speakers of other languages. Both articles used innovative forms of communication, the first posting links in just about every sentence, and the second combining twitter posts with a traditional news story.

We don't need stories like these to let us know that new, more flashy and lighthearted ways of communicating are changing the way we look at the world. The Obama campaign may not have been won through tumblr and memes, but if the students at my school were voting, it certainly would have been. Students who knew nothing about policies were quite well informed about Mitt Romney's latest blunders. The Obama campaign shows what effective internet communication can look like, leading me to wonder, what would effective internet communication look like in schools?

I have to admit, I was not won over by the iLit series' take on microfiction and twitter novels. Somehow putting memes into a print book and sterilizing them according to copyright law seems to suck the life out of them––kids get that. At the same time, if proponents for ELA are going to make a claim for teaching students to "read the world," as both authors we studied this term do, teachers need to be engaging students in relevant forms of communication. The ability to do so will be one of the benefits teachers reap with the advent of technology in the classroom. This blog itself has allowed us to explore the benefits of alternative forms of communication in context, and I for one have found its informal style liberating and comfortable. Of course, as with anything new, there will be concerns to mirror the benefits, but the fact is that students already are engaged in this form of communication. Like it or not, we're going to have to find a way to catch up.

"Anyone who tries to make a distinction between education and entertainment doesn't know the first thing about either."

-Marshal McLuhan